BreakingWILDERNESS OF PARANThe Night the People Wept for NothingJERUSALEMYirmiyahu Walks Through the Burning CityJERUSALEMTitus Cuts the Curtain and the Gold Runs Down Between the StonesWARSAW GHETTOCzerniaków Swallows Cyanide Rather Than Sign for the Children
Vol. I · No. IXט׳ באב · The Ninth of AvPrice: One Kinah

The Tishah be-Av Chronicle

“How does the city sit solitary, that was full of people” — Eichah 1:1

WAR & DESTRUCTION · Lead Dispatch

Titus Cuts the Curtain and the Gold Runs Down Between the Stones

On the very same day the First Temple fell, the Second Temple falls. A burning stick flies through a window of the Sanctuary. The gold plating melts and runs down between the stones. The Roman general walks into the holiest room with a sword. Outside, there are so many dead bodies there are no more crosses left, and no more space for the crosses.

JERUSALEM · 9 Av, 3830 (70 CE) · By Our Correspondent in the Besieged City

Four Roman legions were dug in around Jerusalem. Titus had built an earth wall all the way around the city in three days to catch anyone trying to sneak out. Anyone caught was crucified where the defenders on the wall could see it. Josephus writes that at the worst of it, his soldiers were crucifying up to five hundred people a day, and they eventually ran out of room for crosses and out of crosses for the bodies.

Inside the walls, starvation had gone past hunger into places human beings are not supposed to go. Josephus records — plainly, in the middle of a paragraph, like a shopping list — a woman named Miriam bat Boetos, once wealthy, driven mad by hunger, who killed and ate her own baby. Rebel soldiers smelled the cooking and broke into her house demanding a share. She uncovered what was left. They ran. When the story reached the Roman camp, even Titus's hardened soldiers cried.

On the seventeenth of Tammuz, exactly as had happened at the First Temple, the daily offering stopped because there was no sheep. The Roman fortress just north of the Temple fell. Then the outer courts. On the ninth of Av — the exact anniversary of the Babylonian fire — Roman soldiers broke through the last defenses of the Sanctuary itself. A soldier, apparently against Titus's own orders, threw a burning stick through a window of the Sanctuary. Within an hour the whole thing was in flames.

Continue Reading →

How to Read This Chronicle

These are stories, not entries in a chronicle of dates. Each dispatch opens on a person and follows them through what happened — a servant at the wrong doorway, an old rabbi weeping at a telegram, soldiers weeping as they carry residents out of their own homes. They are arranged in the order in which they occurred, from a night of weeping in the wilderness to a week of ruined houses in Gaza, so that the whole arc reads as one long story. A handful of pieces marked Historical Bridge are not themselves tragedies — they describe how one era gave way to the next, so no reader loses the thread.

The Timeline of the Ninth

24 reports · 8 eras

Read down the spine from the wilderness of Paran to Gush Katif. Every marker is a dispatch — click any headline to open the full article, or press Play Entire Timeline to hear every report narrated in order.

Era

In the Wilderness

From the Exodus to the eve of the Land

  1. DECREE FROM SINAI

    The Night the People Wept for Nothing

    Twelve scouts come back from a walk through the Land carrying a bunch of grapes so heavy it takes two men to lift it. By nightfall the whole camp is crying and demanding to go back to Egypt. By morning the punishment is set: forty years in the desert, and this night will be a night of tears for every generation.

    WILDERNESS OF PARAN·1313 BCE

  2. OBITUARY · Bridge

    The Day the Clouds Went Away

    Moshe walks his older brother up a mountain and takes off his priestly clothes, one piece at a time. When Aharon lies down to die, the clouds that had protected the people for forty years disappear from the sky.

    MOUNT HOR, EDOM·1273 BCE

Era

The First Temple & Its Fall

Shlomo's House to the Babylonian Exile

  1. HISTORICAL BRIDGE · Bridge

    Shlomo Dedicates the House, and the Fire Comes Down

    Seven years of building. Cedar wood from Lebanon. Stones cut in a quarry far away so that no metal tool was ever heard on the mountain. When the young king finishes praying, fire falls from the sky onto the altar and a cloud fills the room so thick the priests can't stand up.

    JERUSALEM·826 BCE

  2. DAYS OF MOURNING · Bridge

    The Crack in the Wall Before the Fire in the House

    Three weeks before the ninth of Av, the calendar itself starts to grieve. Moshe drops the tablets. The daily offering runs out of sheep. The walls of Jerusalem are broken through. A Torah is burned in the street. An idol is set up inside the Temple. Five wounds on a single day.

    JERUSALEM·587 BCE

  3. WAR & DESTRUCTION

    Yirmiyahu Walks Through the Burning City

    For thirty months the Babylonian army has been sitting outside Jerusalem. Now flames are climbing the walls of the Temple, and young priests are on the roof with the keys of the Sanctuary in their hands. The prophet who spent forty years being called a traitor for saying this would happen walks through the ruins tonight and starts writing Eichah.

    JERUSALEM·586 BCE

  4. HISTORICAL BRIDGE · Bridge

    An Old Man Weeping at the Foundation of a Smaller House

    Seventy years after the exile, a Persian king lets the Jews go home. A small group returns and lays a smaller foundation. The young priests blow trumpets and cheer. The old people, who remember Shlomo's Temple, cry so loudly you cannot tell the shouting from the crying.

    BAVEL / JERUSALEM·516 BCE

Era

The Second Temple & Its Fall

Return from Bavel to Roman destruction

  1. HISTORICAL BRIDGE · Bridge

    Between the Temples: A Priest with a Sword

    A Greek king outlaws Shabbat and drags a pig up to the altar. An old priest in a small village pulls out a sword no one thought he still owned. Three years later his son lights the Menorah with oil that lasts eight days. Eighty years later, his family will hand the country to Rome.

    YEHUDAH·167 BCE

  2. HISTORICAL BRIDGE · Bridge

    A Killer Builds the Most Beautiful House Anyone Has Ever Seen

    He murdered his wife. He murdered most of the Sanhedrin. To buy his people's silence he rebuilt their Temple in white marble and gold. The Talmud says plainly: whoever hasn't seen Herod's building has never seen a beautiful building in his life.

    TEMPLE MOUNT, JERUSALEM·19 BCE

  3. SECOND TEMPLE

    A Servant Brings the Wrong Guest to the Party

    A rich man in Jerusalem has a friend named Kamtza and an enemy named Bar Kamtza. He tells his servant, 'Go bring Kamtza.' The servant brings the wrong one. What happens at the doorway will end with the Temple on fire.

    JERUSALEM·64 CE

  4. WAR & DESTRUCTION

    Three Groups Set Fire to Their Own Food

    Rome sends a terrible governor. Rebels stop the daily sacrifice offered for the emperor. A whole Roman legion is wiped out in a mountain pass. The general Vespasian arrives with four legions. And inside the walls of Jerusalem, three rival Jewish groups burn each other's food supplies.

    JUDEA·66 CE

  5. WAR & DESTRUCTION

    Titus Cuts the Curtain and the Gold Runs Down Between the Stones

    On the very same day the First Temple fell, the Second Temple falls. A burning stick flies through a window of the Sanctuary. The gold plating melts and runs down between the stones. The Roman general walks into the holiest room with a sword. Outside, there are so many dead bodies there are no more crosses left, and no more space for the crosses.

    JERUSALEM·70 CE

Era

Under Rome, Into Exile

Bar Kokhba, Beitar, the ploughing of Zion

  1. HISTORICAL BRIDGE · Bridge

    Rabbi Akiva Names a King

    Sixty years after the fire, a Roman emperor bans circumcision and starts building a pagan city on top of the ruined Temple Mount. A warrior with terrifying strength gathers the last fighters of Judea. The greatest sage of the generation looks at him and says the verse: a star has stepped out of Yaakov.

    JUDEA·132 CE

  2. WAR & DESTRUCTION

    The Blood of Beitar Reaches the Sea

    The Star that Rabbi Akiva named turns on his own uncle in a rage and kicks him to death. The walls of the last fortress crack that same day. The Talmud says the horses sank in blood up to their nostrils, and boulders were rolled by that blood all the way to the sea, four miles away.

    BETAR, JUDEA·135 CE

  3. DESECRATION

    The Wicked Rufus Drives a Plough Across the Temple Mount

    Days after Beitar. The Roman governor takes a team of oxen up onto the Temple Mount and drags a plough across the place where the Holy of Holies stood. A prophecy comes true, word for word. Rabbi Akiva sees a fox come out of the ruins — and laughs.

    TEMPLE MOUNT, JERUSALEM·135 CE

Era

Medieval Europe

Crusades and Expulsions

  1. PERSECUTION

    Kalonymus of Mainz Bars the Door — and the Fathers Take Up the Knife

    A pope in France preaches an armed march to Jerusalem. Before the knights even leave Europe, mobs turn on the Jewish communities of the Rhine River — the same communities that produced Rabbeinu Gershom and the teachers of Rashi. Inside the archbishop's palace at Mainz, a thousand Jews choose death rather than the baptismal font.

    CLERMONT / MAINZ·1096 CE

  2. PERSECUTION · Bridge

    One Hundred and Fifty at Clifford's Tower

    A baron who owes them money leads a mob. The Jews of York run to the royal keep. When the tower begins to burn, a rabbi from France gives the ruling: death by our own hand is better than what's waiting at the door. Fathers kill their families. The few who surrender for baptism are killed as they walk out.

    YORK·1190 CE

  3. EXPULSION

    Sixteen Thousand on the Roads to the Channel

    A king with debts he can't pay signs an edict on Shavuot. Every Jew in England has to be out by the ninth of Av. A ship captain drops a family of exiles on a sandbank and sails away as the tide comes in, telling them to call on Moshe if he could split a sea.

    LONDON·1290 CE

  4. EXPULSION

    Dawn Arrests Across the Kingdom of France

    Philip the Fair — a French king who has just emptied his treasury on a war in Flanders and picked a fight with the pope — sends secret orders to every royal officer in France. On a Sunday morning at first light, every Jew in the kingdom is arrested at the same time. They have weeks to leave. Everything they own belongs to the king.

    PARIS·1306 CE

  5. EXPULSION

    The Crown of Sepharad Falls on the Ninth of Av

    Ferdinand and Isabella finish the war to reclaim Spain in January. In March they sign an edict giving every Jew in the kingdom until the summer to convert or leave. Abarbanel begs on his knees at court and offers a fortune. Torquemada marches into the room carrying a crucifix. The community negotiates one small mercy: the ships will sail on the ninth of Av.

    GRANADA / CADIZ·1492 CE

Era

Early Modern

The Chmielnicki massacres and after

  1. PERSECUTION

    Six Thousand Inside the Nemirov Synagogue

    A Cossack officer with a personal grudge starts a general revolt against the Polish nobility. His Ukrainian and Tatar riders sweep west. In town after town — Nemirov, Tulchin, Polonnoye, Bar — the Jews die first. A rabbi names it 'Yeven Metzulah,' the deep mire, and the Council of Four Lands adds a new fast day.

    NEMIROV / TULCHIN·1648 CE

Era

The 20th Century

World War, the Shoah, and terror in the Diaspora

  1. MODERN CATASTROPHE

    The Chafetz Chaim Weeps at the News from Berlin

    A telegram arrives in a small town in what is now Belarus. The old rabbi of Radin reads it and starts to cry. He tells his students this is the beginning of the birth-pangs of the Mashiach — and that the peace that ends this war will plant the seed of one much worse.

    BERLIN / ST. PETERSBURG·1914 CE

  2. MODERN CATASTROPHE

    Czerniaków Swallows Cyanide Rather Than Sign for the Children

    The notices go up on the ghetto walls on the twenty-second of July. The next morning — the ninth of Av — the Grossaktion begins. Six thousand a day are to be brought to the Umschlagplatz. The head of the Judenrat writes one last line in his diary and swallows the pill. Two weeks later, Janusz Korczak walks his two hundred orphans onto the trains.

    WARSAW GHETTO·1942 CE

  3. MODERN CATASTROPHE

    The Renault Van at 9:53 in the Morning

    In downtown Buenos Aires, a seven-story building holds the archives of a hundred years of Argentine Jewish life — welfare offices, schools, the chevra kadisha, the Holocaust-survivor testimonies. A suicide driver sets off 275 kilograms of ammonium nitrate on the sidewalk in front of it. The front wall collapses. Eighty-five people are dead by the end of the day. It is the eve of the ninth of Av.

    BUENOS AIRES·1994 CE

Era

The State of Israel

Expulsion from Gush Katif

  1. MODERN CATASTROPHE

    The Soldiers Weeping in the Doorway of the Neve Dekalim Synagogue

    Nine thousand Israelis are carried out of their own homes by soldiers of their own army, many of them crying as they carry. In Neve Dekalim, the congregants finish evening prayers, kiss the walls, and are lifted off the floor. In Kfar Darom, families sit on the roof of the synagogue and are pried loose one at a time. The synagogues are burned the next week.

    GUSH KATIF·2005 CE

…until the mourning is turned to gladness.